Should fisheries managers implement marine reserves to protect fragile rockfish populations? This week, I’ll tackle the controversial subject of marine reserves. What are they; do they work; and should they be employed to protect rockfish populations and help already depleted populations recover?
Two weeks ago, I discussed rockfish conservation, and last week, I explained how to implement the deep-water release technique for rockfish. If you missed either of those two posts, I suggest you read them to understand the biology and physiology of rockfish and why rockfish populations are fragile and subject to overfishing.
Marine reserves have been developed in certain areas where rockfish have been over-harvested. Before I start discussing the pros and cons of marine reserves, though, I want to differentiate between a few ecological terms I find confusing.
Marine Protected Area (MPA): This broad term covers a variety of management areas, including marine sanctuaries, estuarine research reserves, ocean parks, and marine wildlife refuges. Some MPAs are established to protect ecosystems, while others preserve cultural resources such as shipwrecks and archaeological sites, and still others are established to sustain fisheries production. Nearly all MPAs in the United States allow a variety of human activities, including fishing.
Marine Reserve: A Marine Reserve is a special, restrictive type of MPA where either no or only limited fishing (sport or commercial) and development are allowed. Marine Reserves are sometimes further divided into “Marine Reserves,” and “No-Take Marine Reserves.” When used together, these two terms usually mean managers allow some fishing for certain species in a Marine Reserve but place a ban on all fishing in a No-Take Marine Reserve.
When you add terms such as Marine Parks, Marine Preserves, and National Marine Sanctuaries to the mix, you end up scratching your head, wondering what each designation means. In this post, when I discuss marine reserves, I am talking about the implementation of a distinct area closed to all fishing.
Fisheries managers in the eastern North Pacific have designated several marine reserves in critical rockfish habitat where rockfish have been overfished. By prohibiting fishing in these areas, managers hope to rebuild overfished populations and protect spawning and nursery habitat. By closing an area to all fishing, biologists can protect rockfish not only from anglers who target rockfish but also from anglers who fish for other species and harvest rockfish as by-catch.
Fishermen generally do not like marine reserves because they lose fishing areas. Reserves protecting rockfish are also controversial because studies suggest as much as 20% of rockfish habitat would have to be closed for a reserve to be effective. Also, reserves displace effort and place pressure on open areas.
Some reserves appear to have benefitted local rockfish populations, but biologists are still uncertain about the overall success of reserves for managing rockfish. Since rockfish do not reproduce until they are several years old, though, and since few larvae survive to reach adulthood, it could take years to realize the benefits of rockfish reserves. Are we willing to wait before we judge the efficacy of these protected areas?
I planned to write two posts on rockfish and ended up writing six. The more I learned about these interesting fish, the more questions I had. I hope I found a few readers who are as intrigued by rockfish as I am. Before tackling my next group of fish, I’ll write a few posts on other topics.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Thank you for visiting my website, and don’t forget to sign up for my Mystery Newsletter!
____________________________________________________________________________
Robin Barefield is the author of three Alaska wilderness mystery novels, Big Game, Murder Over Kodiak, and The Fisherman’s Daughter. To download a free copy of one of her novels, watch her webinar about how she became an author and why she writes Alaska wilderness mysteries. Also, sign up below to subscribe to her free, monthly newsletter on true murder and mystery in Alaska.
